Educating
About Civility During Disciplinary Meetings with Students
By Dale Ernst,
Assistant Dean of Students
Rockhurst University
One of the
earliest memories most people have is learning how to treat people
how you would want to be treated. A couple of years ago while watching
a Barney the Dinosaur tape (for the hundredth time) with my very young
children, a song he was singing re-enforced this very idea. This is commonly
known as the Golden Rule.
Unfortunately
as with all rules, it appears the Golden Rule was made to be broken. Students
coming to your university have been exposed to a culture of television
viewing and news coverage that includes at least monthly stories about
road rage, sky rage, and sideline rage (athletic events for all ages).
In addition to news viewing, students today are exposed to other quality
entertainment, such as the Jerry Springer Show, the Ricki Lake and
Jenny Jones Shows. Shock TV sends a very powerful, and at times, negative
message on how adults communicate with each other on a variety of level
and styles.
As educators
it is important for us to model a common sense, proper, and appropriate
approach to civil discourse. So how can we go about role modeling civility
and good behavior standards when working with our students? Different
approaches may prove helpful in many situations:
- Be respectful,
positive, and flexible
- Have
students schedule appointments when they need to see you. While it may
be easy to take a more drop by or casual approach
to meeting with students, scheduling appointments sends students a clearer
message about the seriousness of the meeting and their behavior. By
scheduling a meeting for a specified time you may defuse a situation,
and you will have the discussion in a more professional
setting.
- Offer
solutions, not blame. This helps you to engage the student in a constructive
fashion versus putting them on the defensive, where they will neither
listen nor learn.
- Find
something to agree on. Search out a common ground. It is way to easy
for individuals to focus in on differences, verses attempting to find
similarities or things to agree about. Acknowledge that the meeting
is difficult for both of you.
- If the
meeting get tense stay calm, and speak quietly and slowly. Acknowledge
the persons feelings by letting them know you understand that
he or she is angry. Attempt to explore and resolve the reasons for the
anger. If emotions become to heightened in a meeting, the meeting could
be rescheduled for another day and time to finish the discussion.
Notions
of civility draw on cultural and religious traditions. Although cultural
customs vary, there are far more similarities then differences. It is
nearly impossible to force others to civility, but we can take responsibility
for ourselves. This usually involves the willingness and ability to restrain
impulsive speech and actions. As opposed to providing a roadmap of good
behavior, many individuals could take a detour and model communications
styles as portrayed by the media. It is important to keep at the forefront
the student development perspective of helping students grow and develop.
About the Author
Dale Ernst
is currently the Assistant Dean of Students at Rockhurst University in
Kansas City, Missouri. Dale is working on his PhD. at the University of
Kansas in Higher Education Leadership. He has held a variety of position
in the residence life field at institutions of higher education in Nebraska,
Iowa, Wisconsin and Missouri. Dale is an active member of UMR-ACUHO, JASPA,
and ACAP. Dale received his BA and MA from the University of Northern
Iowa, and an Ed. Specialist Degree from the University of Missouri Kansas
City.